As I have decided to upgrade my aging tripod to the Feisol CT-3343, I needed a new tripod head. I chose a ball head as I enjoy the freedom of movement it provides. Ball heads are available across a wide price range from a few dollars to nearly one thousand. After a lot of research, I decided upon the Markins M10 ball head. I also ordered the Markins PG34N plate to fit my Nikon D70 and also the Markins MP-3 neoprene pouch to protect the head when it is attached to the tripod (it also acts as a storage pouch.) At $340 it is not cheap, but I think it will be able to easily support both my current and planned future body and lenses.
There were some compelling reasons for me choosing this model and this brand. One of the most important considerations when choosing a ball head is the weight it is expected to support. I looked for a head that can support a 70-200mm F2.8 lens, but potentially could support a longer zoom in the future. Many of the cheaper head will start to creep with heavy lenses. As I am hoping to experiment with both HDR and panoramic photography, movements in the ball head will introduce blur to images.
- Positive reviews - Most, if not all of the review that I read were positive. There were minor comments regarding the movement of the panoramic base (rotational movement when forced) even when fully locked, but this did not distract the reviewers from recommending the head.
- Hopefully it will last a lifetime - I am hoping that the combination of the Feisol tripod and Markins M10 ball head will provide me many years of service. A lot of people agree with Thom Hogan, who thinks that most people will eventually end up buying progressively more extensive tripods and heads (as they start to find deficiencies in there current models), and it is better to just ‘bite the bullet’ and spend the money upfront. I agree, and think it will save you money in the long term.
- More support than I will need - The Markins M10 is rated at 90lbs of support. It is widely agreed that you should look for a head that can support 3 times the maximum support requirement. Based upon my current and planned future body and lenses, I believe this should be more than adequate. Also, having some ‘headroom’ will put the head under less stress under day-to-day use.
It is worth keeping in mind the additional cost of body and lens plates, which are around $50 each (L plates cost around $100.) Most of the more expensive and professional ball heads provide support for the Arca-Swiss quick release plates. This allows you to permanently attach a plate to your camera bodies or lenses. The Arca-Swiss plates offer a very stable and secure fit to your camera and quick release plates, as they are custom designed for specific camera and lens models. It also allows you to choose plates from a number of different manufacturers to meet your requirements. Note that Manfrotto ball heads do not support the Arca-Swiss plates, so you will need to buy additional Manfrotto plates if you choose a Manfrotto ball head. I did not find the Manfrotto plates as secure as the Arca-Swiss plates, with some movement when attached. This is mainly due to the generic nature of the Manfrotto plates, as they are designed to fit all available bodies and cameras. A tripod provides a secure and stable environment for low light or longer exposure shots. If any parts of your tripod setup can move, wether it be the legs, head or plates, then your photos may suffer from blur or sharpness issues.
The following are some other models that I looked at before deciding upon the Markins. Note that my budget was around $200 - $400 dollars, hence the lack of expensive models. However as this price range covers most of the popular ball heads, you would only look to spend more if you will be supporting larger (300mm +) lenses. I would recommend either the Kirk BH-1, Markins M20 or RRS BH-55 if more support is required.
- Markins Q-Ball Q3 - the baby brother to the Markins M10, the Q3 is slightly smaller and supports slightly less weight. It was very hard to choose between the Q3 and M10, but I ultimately chose the more expensive model, mainly due its increased support capability.
- Kirk BH-3 - a very popular ball head and its cheaper price ($255) and included universal plate makes a very good alternative to the Markins.
- RRS BH-40 - a work of art that looks fantastic. Most reviews have been positive, but I have read more than once about a slight creep after locking the ball. It is also more expensive at $375 (with lever quick release), but it would definitely be a good alternative to the Markins M10.
- Manfrotto 488 - a pretty good ball head for $100, but at this price point you are not really going to get the same level of support as the more expensive models. It does have a tendency to creep with anything bigger than a small body and zoom lens, so you may end up replacing it when you upgrade you lenses. All Manfrotto heads include a proprietary quick release system. It has become standard among the the more expensive and professional ball head manufactures to support the Arca-Swiss style quick release plates. After you have used the Arca-Swiss quick release plates, the Manfrotto system seems very unstable and cumbersome in comparison.
- Manfrotto 468MG - currently the top-of-the-range from Manfrotto ball head and has received a number of positive reviews. However, at around $290 it is priced similar to the Kirk, Markins and RRS models. Whilst I love Manfrotto products, I think a lot of photographers would recommend the other models. Also, the Manfrotto includes the proprietary quick release system as with the 488.
I am currently awaiting its delivery from Korea, and will be providing both my initial thoughts and a more detailed review after some use.
I have included some photos of the Markins M10 range, traditional black, blue, red and without the Markins quick shoe. The later model will be popular for people wishing to use alternative quick shoes, such as the Really Right Stuff models that are receiving some great reviews.
Please note that if you are from outside the US or Canada, you will need to use the Markins International site. US and Canada orders will be shipped from the US reseller, where all international orders will be shipped directly from Korea. My order was processed the same day and I was sent the shipping EMS details to allow me to track the order online. So far, I agree with a number of the online reviews regarding the very prompt and professional customer service of Markins.